污水处理工艺的技术经济综合评价方法

Comprehensive technical and economic evaluations of sewage treatment processes

摘要:

采用八种国内污水处理厂常见的工艺进行技术经济综合评价，包括普通曝气、水解-好氧、AB法、A/O法、A2/O法、交替式氧化沟、一体式氧化沟和SBR法。通过抽样调查分析比较了这些处理工艺的处理效果、经济水平和工程实施等三大类13个评价因子，建立了多评价因子的参数评价体系并设定其中各项因子的权值。评价采用模糊数学的改进方法，并将评价结果与专家评价进行比较。结果表明，A2/O、A/O、氧化沟三大工艺为较为适用于大中型城市建设中的污水处理厂，其中A2/O的表现尤为突出。

Abstract:

Comprehensive technical and economic evaluations were performed for eight kinds of domestic sewage treatment processes commonly used in wastewater treatment plants in China, including conventional aeration, hydrolysis – aerobic process, AB method, A/O method, A2/O method, alternating type oxidation ditch, integrated oxidation ditch and SBR. Three major categories of total 13 evaluation factors, including treatment effect, economic aspect and project implementation were analyzed and compared through a sampling investigation. A multi-factor evaluation system was established and the factor weights were set. Evaluations were performed with fuzzy mathematics method and the results were compared with those of expert evaluations. Research results showed that A2/O, A/O and oxidation ditch were more applicable to the sewage treatment plants in large or medium-sized cities, among which A2/O was particularly prominent.